Last Updated on March 14, 2024
You can find some of the best places for Key Lime Pie in Orlando.
The official state pie of Florida is key lime pie, with its origins tracing back to Key West.
A delicious key lime pie is a cold pie that consists of a hearty crust (like pastry crust or graham cracker crumbs), a filling of egg yolks, key lime zest, condensed milk, and lime juice, and a meringue topping from egg whites and sugar.
There are lots of inventive variations of this treat out there.
Check out our Authentic Florida Key Lime Pie Recipe.
There are pie shops and local gems located all over the city where you find plentiful helpings of the Sunshine State’s favorite pie.
If you are looking for the best key lime pie in the Orlando area, make sure to check out the places we have listed below.
Table of Contents
Sister Honey’s Key Lime Pie
Located in SoDo, Sister Honey’s is an award-winning dessert shop that sells pies, cakes, and more. This local favorite has been around since 2012.
Their key lime pie is made with hand-squeezed key lime juice, a delicious graham cracker crust, fresh whipped cream, and fresh berries.
They sell freshly prepared slices at the shop and sell whole pies through advanced orders.
Sister Honey’s Key Lime Pie Address: 247 E Michigan St, Orlando, FL 32806
While you are in the area, check out: 10 Best Things to Do in SoDo Orlando
Paddlefish
Located in Disney Springs, Paddlefish is a Disney Signature Dining restaurant that guests can dine at without going into the parks or resort hotels.
Paddlefish is based in a steamboat anchored on Lake Buena Vista and provides a unique culinary experience.
Their dessert menu includes the best key lime pie on Disney property, with a homemade graham cracker crust and meringue topping.
Reservations are highly recommended for this restaurant.
Paddlefish Address: 1670 Buena Vista Dr, Orlando, FL 32830
Columbia Restaurant
Columbia is a family-owned restaurant chain in Florida with quite a history.
Their original Ybor City location in Tampa is the oldest continuously operated restaurant in Florida and the oldest Spanish restaurant in the world.
Columbia’s local location in Celebration is another great Central Florida option for an amazing slice of key lime pie.
Their pie is made with a filling that includes their signature “Nellie & Joe’s” key lime juice, condensed milk, and pasteurized egg yolks.
Columbia Restaurant Address: 649 Front St, Celebration, FL 34747
More information about Columbia Restaurant: 5 Historical Facts About Columbia Restaurant
Valhalla Bakery Vegan Key Lime Pie
If you are looking for a vegan key lime pie, look no further than Valhalla Bakery!
Located within Market on South, a plant-based dining hall in the Milk District, Valhalla is a great place that offers fresh, high-quality vegan comfort food, including a variety of cookies, cakes, and pies.
Try out their key lime pies, which are so delicious that you won’t miss the non-plant-based traditional ingredients.
Make sure to stop by first thing for their best selections.
Valhalla Bakery Address: 5565 Old Cheney Hwy, Orlando, FL 32807
While you are in the area, check out: 4 Best Things to Do in the Orlando Milk District
Charlie’s Bakery and Creamery
Charlie’s Bakery & Creamy has been in Central Florida since 1971.
Located off Curry Ford Road by Crystal Lake Drive, this East Orlando hidden gem serves cakes, cheesecakes, cookies, pastries, pies, and ice cream.
The award-winning shop serves up an incredible key lime pie with a hefty graham cracker shell, signature key lime filling made from fresh key limes, and topped with handmade whipped cream.
Charlie’s Bakery & Creamery Address: Dover Shores Shopping Center, 3213 Curry Ford Rd, Orlando, FL 32806
TIP: Walk over to Clemons Produce a few shops away. They have wonderful local and organic produce, Amish products, and so much more. Plus, they are the nicest people. Shop Local!
Winter Park Pie Company
We made an exception and included Winter Park Pie Company, a pie shop located next door in Winter Park that makes fresh-baked, handmade pies.
They make a variety of delicious flavors of pie that are difficult to find elsewhere, such as gingered pear raspberry, pineapple, and strawberry mango coconut.
Their Florida Key Lime Pie with Graham Cracker Crust is made with the freshest ingredients, which you can order by the pie.
Winter Park Pie Company Address: 1901 Gipson Green Lane, Winter Park , Florida 32789
Additional Orlando Key Lime Pie Places Recommended by Our Readers
1803 Desserts
Address: 1803 Winter Park Rd, Orlando, FL 32803
The Oceanaire Seafood Room
Address: 9101 International Drive, Suite 1002, Orlando, FL 32819
Maxine’s on Shine
Address: 337 Shine Ave, Orlando, FL 32803
Lombardi’s Seafood Market
Address: 1888 W. Fairbanks Ave., Winter Park, FL 32789
The Tap Room at Dubsdread
Address: 549 W. Par Street, Orlando, FL 32804
If you enjoyed this article about the best places to get key lime pie in Orlando and are looking for a few other recommendations, check out these suggestions: