Top Places to Get the Best Cheesecake in Florida (2024)

Last Updated on April 3, 2024

Are you looking for the best cheesecake in Florida? We researched so we could share our findings with you. You’re welcome.

Fun Fact: Cheesecake comes from ancient Greece. It was created as a recipe to serve athletes by the Greek physician Aegimus.

Remember, as you enjoy your slice, that you’re also eating the food of athletes.

Check out our list of the best places to get authentic cheesecake in Florida.

9 Places with the Best Cheesecake – Florida

Bassano Cheesecake, Safety Harbor

Tom and Cindy Bassano serve Safety Harbor and serve the 2nd best cheesecake in Florida at Bassano Cheesecake. Why the second, you may ask? Because “you don’t disrespect your mother, capisce?”

They started by taste-testing Tom’s Aunt Clara’s family recipe on friends and family. Then they created a delicious cheesecake that they delivered to a local deli.

By the time they got home, the phone had rung and they had their first order!

Bassano Cheesecake Cafe now has over 20 flavors at their store on Main Street in Safety Harbor.

They have classic New York Cheesecake as well as Raspberry, Strawberry, Blueberry, Fudge, and Key Lime as standard flavors.

They also offer seasonal flavors throughout the year.

Bassano Cheesecake Address: 507 Main St, Safety Harbor, FL 34695

Chrisoula’s Cheesecake Shoppe, Pensacola

Chrisoula of Chrisoula’s Cheesecake Shoppe grew up learning from her father Spero Athanasios who was a chef/owner of numerous restaurants.

Writings of the first-ever cheesecakes were created on the Greek Island of Samos, where Chrisoula’s father Spero is also from.

In 2005 she made cheesecakes for her family’s restaurant in downtown Pensacola at Cafe 22. The restaurant has been a hit ever since.

Chrisoula and her husband Tony opened their first store in 2007, and currently have a storefront in downtown Pensacola.

Chrisoula’s Cheesecake Shoppe Address: 236 W Garden St # 2a, Pensacola, FL 32502

Coconuts, Fort Lauderdale

With expansive, uninterrupted views of Fort Lauderdale’s intercoastal waterways, Coconuts in Fort Lauderdale is a beautiful dining destination. It’s great to watch the boats cruise by.

If you prefer to travel by boat, you can raft it at their dock.

Chef Luc Limage creates a delicious coconut cheesecake, which always gets rave reviews and is a must-try.

Coconuts Address: 429 Seabreeze Blvd, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301

Dbakers Sweet Studio, Miami

Dbakers Sweet Studio in Miami is family-owned by twins Christian and Giancarlo Guevara. They pride themselves on creating a workplace where people can be creative, colorful, and have fun.

Once business started booming, they added their award-winning cake artist cousin, Katherine Van Der Biest, to the team. They also opened their first store in Midtown Miami.

They have another store opening soon in South Miami.

Dbakers Sweet Studio Address: 3501 NE 2nd Ave, Miami, FL 33137

Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop & Cafe, Miami and Wynwood

Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop and Cafe serves not only delicious cheesecake. You can find pies, cakes, cookies, empanadas, brownies, bars, bread puddings, coffee, and more.

They sell everything as individual servings, by the slice, or as a whole cake, pie, or cheesecake for special occasions.

All of the recipes are Fireman Derek’s originals that are tested and approved by actual firefighters.

Check out the other things to do in these areas: Miami and Wynwood.

Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop and Cafe Miami Address: 3435 Main Hwy, Miami, FL 33133
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop and Cafe Wynwood Address: 2545 N Miami Ave Bay 1, Miami, FL 33127
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop and Cafe Fort Lauderdale Address: 250 N Federal Hwy Suite 1, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company, Cocoa Beach

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company in Cocoa Beach is an amazing shopping destination for both locals and tourists alike! It’s located next to the famous Ron Jon Surf Shop.

Not only do they serve delicious Key Lime Pie, but they also have dozens of cheesecake flavors.

We recommend Caribbean Chocolate Marble, Tropical Guava, Island Mango, and Vanilla Bean.

Make sure to check out their fun Florida decor.

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company Address: 102 Dixie Lane, Cocoa Beach, FL 32931

Make it a day trip with our favorite things to do on Florida’s Space Coast.

Kneading More Sweets, Ormond Beach

Kneading More Sweets in Ormond Beach says, “We make sweets, so you can make memories.”

They pride themselves on being a memory-making business. They bake cheesecakes, cakes, and treats for you and your loved ones to enjoy.

In addition, they use original and long-kept family recipes that have been perfected over the lives of two master bakers.

Stop by their stores in Ormond Beach and DeLand for a treat baked in-house.

Ormond Beach Kneading More Sweets Address: 175 S Nova Rd, Ormond Beach, FL 32174

Deland Kneading More Sweets Address:115 E Rich Ave, DeLand, FL 32724

Lake Mary Cheesecake, Altamonte Springs

Next on our list of the best cheesecake in Florida is Lake Mary Cheesecake. They offer over 50 flavors and varieties of cheesecake and the option of customization.

Since 1999, Lake Mary Cheesecake Company in Seminole County has been serving delicious high-quality desserts.

All of the ingredients they use are natural and fresh. They also use the “bain-marie” baking style with constant observation, control, and patience. 

Ask about their incredible no-gluten, no-dairy, low-fat, low-carb, and no-sugar varieties.

Lake Mary Cheesecake Address: 840 Sunshine Ln, Altamonte Springs, FL 32714

Super Day Express, Port Charlotte 

Super Day Express of Port Charlotte is a full-service convenience store and restaurant. It is a one-stop shop for fishermen and people of the community.

They offer cheesecake and other homemade foods to take with you. You can pick it up or have it delivered.

Their owner has over five decades of years of experience in the restaurant business. However, they decided to move from New Jersey to Florida to open this one-stop convenience store.

Just like New Jersey diners are famous for having a diverse list of menu items and everything is great tasting. You’ll have the same experience at Super Day Express.

Super Day Express Address: 1595 S McCall Rd, Port Charlotte, FL 33981

Looking for more sweets in Florida?

• Best Key Lime Pie In Orlando
• 7 Best Places to Get Key Lime Pie in Miami
• 7 Best Places to Get Key Lime Pie in Tampa
• The 14 Best Key Lime Pies in the Florida Keys
• Best Ice Cream Shops in Florida
• Strawberry Cake Recipe
• Best Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurants in Orlando
• Delicious Black-Owned Restaurants in Florida