Last Updated on March 14, 2024
There are many great, authentic places to get key lime pie in Tampa – in fact, there’s no shortage throughout Florida from the Keys to Orlando and beyond.
Key Lime Pie is Florida’s favorite pie (which is also the official state pie).
If you’re craving excellent key lime pie, head over to the west coast of Florida for key lime pie in Tampa!
Key lime pie is a delicious combination of crust and a key-lime-based filling.
There are a lot of different variations out there: some bakers use pastry crusts, and some use graham cracker crusts; some top their pies with whipped cream, and some prefer a meringue topping.
There are many ways to go about making this dessert, as you’ll see amongst the best Tampa places listed in this article.
Check out our Florida Key Lime Pie Recipe.
If you are looking for the best key lime pie in the Tampa area, make sure to check out the places we have listed below.
There are pie shops and local gems located all over the city where you will find plentiful helpings of the Sunshine State’s favorite pie.
We’ve also added a few spins on the pie by showcasing key lime cheesecake, key lime cupcakes and key lime ice cream.
Mike’s Pies
Mike’s Pies is a pie shop on Tampa’s east side. They make a nationally-ranked key lime pie out of egg yolks, condensed milk, and lime juice.
The filling is on a graham cracker crust made from graham cracker, brown sugar, and butter.
The simplicity of the ingredients lists goes to show that a winning pie doesn’t need a bunch of bells and whistles.
Mike’s Pies key lime pie is sold by the whole pie, with regular and deep dish options.
Mike’s Pies Address: 10350 Windhorst Rd #100, Tampa, FL 33619
Alessi Bakery
Alessi Bakery has been in Tampa since 1912, opened by Italian immigrant Nicolo Alessi. Four generations have carried on the family business.
The historic restaurant establishment has a bakery and deli.
They serve tasty key lime pies as mousse cakes, 3-inch mousse cream pies, and individual tartlets.
Alessi Bakery Address: 2909 W Cypress St, Tampa, FL 33609
Columbia Restaurant
Located in the Ybor City neighborhood of Tampa, Columbia is the oldest continuously operated restaurant in Florida and the oldest Spanish restaurant in the world.
Included on their menu is an amazing slice of key lime pie.
Their pie is made with a filling that includes the signature “Nellie & Joe’s” key lime juice, condensed milk, and pasteurized egg yolks.
Columbia Restaurant Address: 2117 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605
More information about Columbia Restaurant: 5 Historical Facts About Columbia Restaurant
SugarDarlings Cupcakes
SugarDarlings Cupcakes is a gourmet cupcake shop. They are known for having a long list of cupcake flavors to choose from.
They serve up a lot of unique flavors, like caramel mocha latte, lemon lavender, peanut butter & jelly, and wasabi ginger.
Try their delectable key lime pie cupcake with a whipped topping that the shop makes fresh daily.
SugarDarlings Cupcakes Address: 11751 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618
Bright Ice
Bright Ice is a handcrafted small-batch ice cream shop.
Like SugarDarlings, they have a bunch of fun and unique flavors to choose from, like pineapple with brown butter and pecans, coffee toffee, and blueberries with cinnamon.
Their key lime pie flavor is sweet and tart, with graham cracker crust mixed into the ice cream for an inventive and tasty spin on a traditional key lime pie.
Bright Ice Address: 505 Water St Suite A-01, Tampa, FL 33602
Ulele
Ulele is a Tampa Heights restaurant that serves Native American fusion dishes.
Their menu includes a variety of seafood dishes, such as Gulf Coast oysters, blackened redfish, and mahi-mahi, as well as chilis, salads, and sides.
On their dessert menu, they have many great options, but their Key West Key Lime Stack is the one you can’t miss. It is a fluffy and creamy rendition of pie served with brûléed meringue.
Ulele Address: 1810 N Highland Ave, Tampa, FL 33602
If you enjoyed this article about the best places to get key lime pie in Tampa and are looking for a few other recommendations, check out these suggestions: