Last Updated on March 4, 2024
The best places to get key lime pie in Miami are a must-visit on your next Florida trip! In case you didn’t know, key lime pie is the official pie of the state of Florida.
The iconic dessert consists of some basic ingredients: a crust, usually a pastry crust or a good graham cracker crust, and a creamy filling made with real key limes. The pie is often topped with whipped cream or meringue and is beloved for its unique flavor.
While the history of key lime pie originates back to the late 1800s in the Florida Keys, there are plenty of places all over the Sunshine State where you can find and indulge in this tangy dessert.
Orlando, Tampa, and many other cities have plenty of shops and restaurants that serve amazing key lime pie – including Miami!
Miami is a great city to check out for some of the best pies. It is a short distance from the pie’s place of origin in the Florida Keys. These pies are local favorites that use authentic key limes to create the perfect key lime pie.
Best key lime pie in Miami:
We’re including some of our favorite places in Miami to enjoy amazing key lime pie, whether you are searching for a slice of key lime pie or a whole pie!
A Fish Called Avalon
A Fish Called Avalon is a Miami Beach restaurant located on the infamous Ocean Drive. It is one of the top seafood dining spots in South Florida, with live Latin-Caribbean music nightly.
This is a must-visit spot for key lime pie, as the American Pie Council awarded the distinction of the Best Key Lime Pie to A Fish Called Avalon during its 25th Annual National Pie Championships.
This restaurant’s key lime pie is set apart because it is pecan-crusted, which complements its light and tart flavor. Having “bested” over 470 other entries in the national competition, this is a great place to try some famous key lime pie.
A Fish Called Avalon Address: 700 Ocean Dr, Miami Beach, FL 33139
Blue Collar
Located on Biscayne Boulevard, Blue Collar is a restaurant that serves some delicious comfort food. The menu includes small bites, salads, sandwiches, and some hearty entrees and veggie options.
Their Hand Squeezed Key Lime Pie is one of the best in Miami with a filling made with real key lime juice, a graham cracker crust, and topped with fresh whipped cream. This is another great stop for our favorite dessert!
Blue Collar Address: 6730 Biscayne Blvd, Miami, FL 33138
Joe’s Stone Crab
Joe’s Stone Crab has a history that dates back to 1913 with a lunch stand in Miami. Today, the Miami Beach restaurant is still owned by the same family. It is known for its delicious and authentic seafood options, comfort sides, and amazing desserts.
Joe’s Key Lime Pie can be ordered by the slice, or if you want a whole pie, you can purchase it for pick up or delivery! The pies are baked fresh daily with a tasty graham cracker crust.
Joe’s Stone Crab Address: 11 Washington Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33139
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop
Derek Kaplan is a former Miami firefighter and the creator behind Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop. Known as the best bake shop in Miami, the menu features another award-winning key lime pie option.
It’s not just one of our favorites, Derek’s Key Lime Pie was voted Miami’s Best Key Lime Pie by the Miami New Times. Starting with a crushed graham cracker crust, the pie has a filling made from hand-squeezed key limes that make up a perfect combination of sweet and tart.
Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop Addresses: 2545 N. Miami Ave Bay 1, Miami FL 33127 & 3435 Main Hwy, Miami, FL 33133.
Fookem’s Fabulous
Fookem’s Fabulous is a shop located in Miami’s charming Coconut Grove district that is recognized especially for its key lime pies. Using a signature sea salt graham cracker crust, Fookem’s flagship menu item is a Classic Key Lime Pie.
The pie has a tangy key lime filling that pairs perfectly with the graham cracker crust and is available in both mini and full-size pies.
Fookem’s Fabulous Address: 3081 Oak Ave. Miami, FL 33133
Pinecrest Bakery
Pinecrest Bakery is a South Florida chain that is known for its modern twist on traditional Cuban food. The menu includes delicious pastelitos, empanadas, croquetas, and more.
On the dessert menu, there are some great key lime options, including key lime tarts, key lime pie by the slice, and whole key lime pie.
Pinecrest Bakery Address: Multiple Locations
Icebox Café
Icebox Café is a Miami Beach restaurant that fuses comfort food with style. Additionally, they are a popular brunch spot with a wide variety of food options, including vegan and vegetarian entrees.
The café’s Deep Dish Key Lime Pie is one of the best in Miami, with a graham cracker crust and a key lime custard topped with whipped cream for a rich and delicious dessert.
Icebox Café Address: 1855 Purdy Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33139
If you want to try your hand at homemade key lime pie, check out our Key Lime Pie Recipe.
If you enjoyed this article about the best places to get key lime pie in Miami and are looking for a few other recommendations, check out these suggestions: